Screening for Conflict Minerals: Columbite-Tantalite and Beyond

Diggity Geochemistry, Independent Studies, LIBS, News & Press

One important application for SciAps handheld LIBS is the identification of the geographic source of so-called “conflict minerals,” which are used as raw materials for components of consumer electronics. Such information helps companies and their customers understand whether their purchasing decisions are supporting conflicts in war zones.

Dr. Richard Hark was among the first to pursue this application for laboratory LIBS in the years before SciAps made the first handheld LIBS. Hark published two articles with undergraduate students: “Can the provenance of the conflict minerals columbite-tantalite be ascertained by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy?” (Anal. Bioanal. Chem, 2011) and “Geographical analysis of ‘conflict minerals’ utilizing laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy” (Spectrochim. Acta B, 2012). Both articles discussed using a laboratory LIBS for geochemical fingerprinting, which allowed the researchers to identify the geological provenance for columbite and tantalite (also known as “coltan”) from Africa and other locations with a high level of certainty.

These studies paved the way for industrial partners to comply with the U.S. Dodd-Frank Act of 2010, which mandated that manufacturers report whether their tin, niobium and tantalum, tungsten and gold (extracts of cassiterite, columbite-tantalite and wolframite) had been obtained from conflict-affected and high-risk areas.

In 2014, with the SciAps handheld LIBS available, Hark realized that an easily operable handheld analyzer would be perfect for this application.

“LIBS can help address the question of where the conflict minerals come from, not because it offers 100% certainty, but because it’s a fast, presumptive screening tool. If you had a sample of the coltan, you could pick it up, zap it, and in a matter of 20 seconds, you could have an answer to where the sample came from with some reasonable level of confidence,” says Hark.

He wrote to a well-known electronics company based in the U.S. about their supply-chain issue and suggested that handheld LIBS could help them verify their paperwork.

The CEO connected Hark with the head of their supply chain initiative, who was interested in exploring the use of LIBS, but by then, the Washington, D.C., Circuit Court ruled that the Dodd-Frank Act requirement “violates the prohibition against compelled speech. By compelling an issuer to confess blood on its hands, the statute interferes with that exercise of freedom of speech under the First Amendment.”

After the rule was suspended in 2017, interest in geochemical fingerprinting evaporated from many industrial partners. However, the articles Hark published with his undergraduate students opened unexpected doors. “One of my students was invited to speak about their research at an event in Washington, D.C., that also featured the Director of the National Science Foundation. That was a great opportunity for an undergraduate student!” says Hark.

The articles have also led to other manufacturing and electronics companies contacting Hark. Many companies continue working to identify conflict minerals in their products to comply with international standards that require manufacturers to map supply chains, identify, assess and mitigate risks, as well as report publicly on their actions and outcomes.

Apple, Alphabet (Google), HP, Microsoft, and Intel are leaders in this work.

With the SciAps handheld LIBS, companies could more easily reach these goals, whether directly or through third-party verification companies.

“If you had a sample of the coltan, you could pick it up, zap it, and in a matter of 20 seconds, you could have an answer to where the sample came from with some reasonable level of confidence.”
— Dr. Richard Hark

Publications

“Geochemical Fingerprinting by Handheld Laser‐Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy” (2017)
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/ggr.12175 (abstract only, link to paid purchase)

“Geochemical Fingerprinting Using LIBS” (2014)
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-642-45085-3_12 (link to book)

“Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy: A Closer Look at the Capabilities of LIBS Part 1” (2014) 
https://www.spectroscopyonline.com/view/laser-induced-breakdown-spectroscopy-closer-look-capabilities-libs 

“Fingerprinting Conflict Minerals: Spectroscopic method could help identify mineral origins” (2012)
https://cen.acs.org/articles/90/i18/Fingerprinting-Conflict-Minerals.html


Articles about companies eliminating conflict minerals

Many Companies Struggle to Comply with Conflict Mineral Reporting Rules (2020)

“The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) annual report Conflict Minerals: Actions Needed to Assess Progress Addressing Armed Groups’ Exploitation of Minerals examines a sample of filings from 1,083 companies that submitted conflict mineral disclosures required by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 2019. According to the GAO, about half of companies that performed initial research in 2019 were able to determine where their conflict minerals came from, echoing findings in 2017 and 2018.”
https://www.newsecuritybeat.org/2020/09/companies-struggle-comply-conflict-mineral-reporting-rules/

New Conflict Minerals Rankings Spotlight World’s Top Consumer Electronics Companies and Jewelry Retailers (2017)

“Apple is clear leader in supporting a conflict-free minerals trade; Walmart, Sears and Neiman Marcus are ranked worst; Rankings show steady advances on conflict-free sourcing from Congo, but urgent need for more action to ensure products aren’t linked to mass atrocities and human rights abuses.”
https://enoughproject.org/press-releases/new-conflict-minerals-rankings-spotlight-worlds-top-consumer-electronics-companies-jewelry-retailers


See how SciAps handheld analyzers are working in the field

and how researchers are using SciAps LIBS and XRF analyzers to expand the world of elemental analysis.

In-field chemistry everywhere with handheld LIBS

Russell Harmon, Ph.D., adjunct associate professor, Department of Marine, Earth, & Atmospheric Sciences, North Carolina State University Russell Harmon: A vision for the future of LIBS SciAps debuted the world’s first truly portable handheld only a few years ago, but ...

In-field analysis of rock varnish with SciAps LIBS

Publication: Russell S. Harmon, Daria Khashchevskaya, Michelle Morency, Lewis A. Owen, Morgan Jennings, Jeffrey R. Knott and Jason M. Dortch. “Analysis of Rock Varnish from the Mojave Desert by Handheld Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy,” Molecules 26, 5200 (2021). This study investigated ...

SciAps LIBS helps scientists prepare for Mars

SciAps Z-903 LIBS analyzer joins Hawai‘i Space Exploration Analog and Simulation with scientist Sarafina Nance on their Mars simulation mission August 13-27, 2021. For updates on the mission in real time, follow @HI-SEAS on Twitter. HI-SEAS is a Mars and ...

Analysis of garnet by LIBS — two practical applications

Publication: Peter A. Defnet, Michael A. Wise, Russell S. Harmon, Richard R. Hark and Keith Hilferding. “Analysis of Garnet by Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy—Two Practical Applications,” Minerals 11, 705 (2021). This study evaluated two practical applications of handheld LIBS using SciAps ...

Advances in LIBS analysis for geology: A critical review

Publication: Cécile Fabre, University of Lorraine. “Advances in Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy analysis for geology: A critical review,” Spectrochimica Acta Part B Atomic Spectroscopy 166:105799 (2020). A review of studies demonstrates LIBS is the optimal way to achieve quick geology screening ...

Application of Handheld LIBS to Quantitative Analysis of Carbonate Minerals

Presented at International Online Meeting on Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (IOMLIBS), July 2020. Authors: Yonghwi Kim, University of Lorraine; Cécile Fabre, University of Lorraine; Jean Cauzid, University of Lorraine Handheld LIBS is effectively applicable for in-field determination of carbonates and ...

Analyses of Li-Rich Minerals Using Handheld LIBS

Publication: Cécile Fabre, Nour Eddine Ourti, Julien Mercadier, Joana Cardoso-Fernandes, Filipa Dias, Mônica Perrotta, Friederike Koerting, Alexandre Lima, Friederike Kaestner, Nicole Koellner, Robert Linnen, David Benn, Tania Martins and Jean Cauzid. “Analyses of Li-Rich Minerals Using Handheld LIBS Tool,” Data. ...

Investigation of handheld LIBS in terms of heavy metal detection in contaminated soil

Study presented to  Interdisciplinary Laboratory for Continental Environments, September 2020. Authors: Mehran Movahedrad, LafargeHolcim, Lyon, France; Cécile Fabre, University of Lorraine SciAps LIBS was used to perform heavy metals analysis in contaminated soil. Handheld LIBS simplifies the necessary qualitative and ...

Making a case for handheld LIBS in mineral exploration

Dr. Cécile Fabre, assistant professor at GeoRessources lab, is head of the Earth Sciences Department of Université de Lorraine and responsible for Master of Geosciences. She has been working on LIBS applications for mineral exploration since the end of the ...

Invited review: “Field-portable and handheld LIBS history, status and prospects”

Publication: Giorgio S. Senesi, Russell S. Harmon, Richard R. Hark. Field-portable and handheld laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy: Historical review, current status and future prospects. Spectrochimica Acta Part B: Atomic Spectroscopy, 175 (2021). SciAps LIBS is included in this invited review of ...

SciAps CTO Dave Day in ‘Portable Spectroscopy and Spectrometry’

Day contributes definitive guide to emerging handheld LIBS technology, in a new volume published by Wiley SciAps, Inc. a Boston-based company specializing in handheld analytical instrumentation, is pleased to announce that CTO Dave Day has contributed a chapter on handheld ...

SciAps Test Station for lab, field, and field-lab

Use it in field, or bring it to the bench The XRF Test Station is designed for reliability, durability and safety, complete with interlocked lid for your protection and a super stable base to keep your samples positioned correctly regardless ...

SciAps, Inc. is a leading manufacturer of handheld XRF and LIBS analyzers, able to measure virtually every element, in almost any material. These breakthrough instruments have been expanding applications for portable, in-field measurements of elements, minerals and compounds in every major industry around the world. Sign up for our e-mail list to be the first to hear about this expanding world of handheld analysis.

Need an academic loaner? We frequently loan handheld analyzers for a few weeks or a month to academic researchers from the U.S. and Canada, so that they can perform a study or field analysis anywhere in the world. LIBS is often a preferred technique, especially for students, since operators do not have to deal with the regulatory complexities of X-ray fluorescence analyzers. And our accompanying ProfileBuilder software provides operators complete freedom to modify parameters. You’re not limited to factory-imposed calibrations or unchangeable multi-variant techniques. Contact us with a brief description of what you want to measure.

Share this Post